Family members' attitudes towards telling the patient with Alzheimer's disease their diagnosis: a 20-year repeat study. O'Brien MMC, et al, Eur Geriatr Med 2021.
- Proposé le : 03/06/2021 12:07:04
- Par : Bot Twitter
- Avec la version du site : v2021_01_12
- Revu par :
- Mettre votre nom d'utilisateur
- Mettre votre nom d'utilisateur
Résumé et points clés
Purpose: Exploring family members' attitudes to an Alzheimer's disease diagnosis compared to that of a study 20 years prior by Maguire et al. (BMJ 313:529-530, 1996).
Methods: The survey was a replica of that completed 20 years prior in the same department by Maguire et al. (BMJ 313:529-530, 1996). With ethics approval and consent, family members were surveyed regarding their attitudes towards a dementia diagnosis. Completed by doctors with 100 consecutive respondents accompanying patients to scheduled memory clinic appointments. Themes were generated, results compiled and compared to the previous study.
Results: Respondents are now over four times more likely to favour disclosure over non-disclosure to a patient (chi-squared 68.142, p < 0.0001). A substantial decrease is evident in those listing fear of evoking a negative reaction. Accordingly, there is an increase in those referring to the benefits of disclosure.
Conclusion: The emerged theme was that of autonomy versus paternalism, with attitude shift reflecting that patient privacy is an established patient right, taking precedence over paternalistic preferences.
Methods: The survey was a replica of that completed 20 years prior in the same department by Maguire et al. (BMJ 313:529-530, 1996). With ethics approval and consent, family members were surveyed regarding their attitudes towards a dementia diagnosis. Completed by doctors with 100 consecutive respondents accompanying patients to scheduled memory clinic appointments. Themes were generated, results compiled and compared to the previous study.
Results: Respondents are now over four times more likely to favour disclosure over non-disclosure to a patient (chi-squared 68.142, p < 0.0001). A substantial decrease is evident in those listing fear of evoking a negative reaction. Accordingly, there is an increase in those referring to the benefits of disclosure.
Conclusion: The emerged theme was that of autonomy versus paternalism, with attitude shift reflecting that patient privacy is an established patient right, taking precedence over paternalistic preferences.
Références de l'article
Discussion
- Cette section peut être éditée par les relecteurs, les rédacteurs, les modérateurs et les administrateurs. Elle regroupe l'ensemble des échanges autours de la référence ci-dessus présentée.
- Référez-vous à cette page pour connaître le rôle des utilisateurs et pour participer à la discussion.
- Il n'y a, pour l'instant, aucune discussion en cours.